| Name |
Class |
Award, Organization |
Year |
| Ralph "Red" Long |
1932 |
AP Honorable Mention |
1930 |
| Bernard "Barney" Marcus |
1937 |
Collier's Honorable Mention |
1936 |
| Charles Cooke Jr. |
1938 |
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1937 |
| Dick Preston |
1938 |
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1937 |
| Gus Clough |
1939 |
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1937 |
|
|
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1938 |
| Charles Crooker |
1940 |
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1938 |
| Norm Parent |
1950 |
AP Little All-America, Third Team |
1946 |
| Art Blanchard |
1950 |
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1946 |
|
|
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1947 |
| Bob Chumbook |
1955 |
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1953 |
| Bob Martin |
1957 |
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1956 |
| Jim Wylie |
1960 |
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1959 |
| Howard Vandersea |
1963 |
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1960 |
|
|
AP Little All-America, Third Team |
1962 |
|
|
Paul Williamson's Little All-America |
1962 |
| Ed Wilson |
1962 |
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1961 |
| Sandy Nesbitt |
1970 |
AP Little All-America, Honorable Mention |
1967 |
| Larry DiGiammarino |
1982 |
Kodak-American Football Coaches Association College Division III |
1981 |
| Chris Hickey |
1988 |
Honorable Mention, AP Little All-America |
1986 |
|
|
Honorable Mention, AP Little All-America |
1987 |
| Rob Gabbe |
1988 |
Honorable Mention, AP Little All-America |
1987 |
| Jason Coulie |
2000 |
Honorable Mention, USAFootball.com |
1999 |
| Frost Hubbard |
2000 |
Honorable Mention, D3Football.com |
1999 |
